Descendants of Jacob and Elizabeth VanMeter Swank through David and Amanda Miller Swank
By Charlotte
Carl-Mitchell
Adapted from the
article for
the Summit newsletter in 2003
According to notes
compiled by Ed
Carl, Jr., the Swanks were part of the group of early Americans called
Pennsylvania Dutch. (The Dutch was a corruption of Deutsch, meaning
German.)
This name was applied to Swiss, German and even French Huguenots who
arrived in
America in the 1700s and early 1800s and settled in south-central and
eastern
Pennsylvania. Almost all of these immigrants came from the area of
South
Germany known as The Palatinate so they were called Palatines. The
Swanks
initially arrived and settled in Pennsylvania but later migrated to
Kentucky as
recruited members of one of Daniel Boone's return trips. Later,
probably
because of Indian uprisings in Kentucky, they moved to what is now
Mississippi
County in Missouri.
My great grandmother,
Mary
Elizabeth Swank Carl said that some of her Swanks fought in the
American
Revolution under Gen. Mad Anthony Wayne, but I haven't been able to
verify
that. She also said her Swanks were related to "Molly Pitcher" (the
heroine of the Revolutionary War who tore off her petticoat to swab out
the
American cannons and brought pitchers of water to the men and her
husband in an
artillery battery at the Battle of Monmouth). I've not been able to
verify that
either.
Jacob Swank was born
on 28 Jan
1776 in Monongalia, Virginia/Pennsylvania. He married Elizabeth Van
Meter 20
Apr 1797 in Hardin Co., Kentucky; and died in 1853 in Mississippi
County,
Missouri. Elizabeth Van Meter was of Dutch descent, born on 25 July
1780 to
Abraham and Elizabeth Cline (or Kline) Van Meter. Elizabeth Van Meter
Swank
died on 15 Sept 1846. Both Jacob and Elizabeth were buried in
Mississippi
County. They had eleven children:
John Swank (1798-1866) married Sarah Lee
Letitia (Lettice) Swank (1799-1851) married Garrard Goodin
Jacob Swank Jr. (1804-1894) married Mary Quigley
William Swank (1807-1889) married Lettie Ashby or Lettia Van
Meter
Eleanor Swank (1809-1851) married (1) Thomas Vernon, (2) Joseph
Dyson
Catherine Swank (1812-1867) married John Goodin
Elizabeth Swank (1813-1845) married James Washington Smith
Sarah Swank (1816- )
married (1) James Alton, (2) James Crutcher
Silas Swank (1819-1885) married (1) Sarah Thompson Randall, (2)
Frances
Thompson
** David Swank (1823-1906) married
Amanda Miller
Mary Swank
The Jacob Swank house still exists in Charleston, Missouri and is on a
list of historic homes. Sadly, it's owned by a descendant who hasn't
maintained it. Another descendant, Cory Hutchison has started a
campaign to restore and save it.
According to my notes
and pages
from the family Bible, David Swank was born on 15 Sept 1823 in Hardin
County,
Kentucky. [Mr. Glen Summit says it was 23 Sept 1823.] David was
approximately
13 years of age when his family moved from Kentucky to Charleston,
Missouri in
1836. Charleston is in the southeastern most corner of the state in an
area
called Missouri's Bootheel because of the shape of the area that abuts
Illinois, Kentucky, Tennessee and Arkansas. David married Amanda Miller
on 15
Mar 1849 in Arkansas.
The map shows
Charleston, MO
marked in yellow and Hardin, KY in pink. (The image is from the
Sikeston Miner
Missouri website: http://rosecity.net/sikeston/links.html.)
David and his siblings
lived at a
turbulent time in American history. We have a photocopy of a letter
Silas Swank
wrote his brother David on 19 Dec 1860 in which he talks about the
trials and
tribulations of his family - a bad bout with measles over the winter,
the death
of a child and other illnesses. But he also included happy news, that
“our
niece, Beck McFarland and Dr. Simpson is about to get married ... as I
believe
also May Swank and Price Lane also, Laura and Thomas Beckwith.” They
had had a
good corn crop and the wheat looked fine but the river had been very
low so
freight costs were high. It was at this point he mentioned his fear the
Union
would split and launched into a diatribe against those "professinal men
who are willing to bow their heads and ware old Abe Linkins yok." He
might
not have been educated or a good speller, but he was aware of what was
going on
around him.
We also have a copy of
a letter
David Swank wrote to his niece, by marriage, Mrs. Emma Embree in 1896.
After
some research, I was able to identify Mrs. Embree and discover her
relationship
to David. Mary Emma Fairly (or Fairleigh) was born on 31 Mar 1851 in
Union
Church, Jefferson Co., Mississippi. She married James William Swank on
2 June
1870. James was born on 17 Jan 1832 in Kentucky. He was the son of
David's
brother Jacob Swank, Jr. and his wife Mary Quigley. According to Paul
C.
Summitt, "Jacob Swank Jr. (1804-1894) apparently lived in Hardin County
until the mid-1830s and then went to Missouri with his father. Both a Jacob Swank and a Jacob Swank
Jr. are listed in the 1840 census for Scott county, Missouri, which in
1845
would give birth to Mississippi county." Jacob Jr. and Mary had two
other
children. Their son, John Swank died at 12 years of age. Another son,
Jacob
"Jake" Swank married Martha Miller, David's wife Amanda's sister, and
had one son who also died young. It might seem strange for David's
nephew to
marry David's sister-in-law since David and Jake would be of two
different
generations, but Jake's father Jacob, Jr. was 19 years older than David.
James William or
'Wills' was married
before Emma to Mary Ellen McDonald. There seems to be a disagreement
about how
many children resulted from which marriage. Karalee Goranflo listed
four
children from the first marriage and five from the second, but in her
list two
of the children's names repeat. Mrs. Elma Rust, a genealogist who
worked with
my father in 1979 and the early 1980s, said there were two children
from the
first marriage to Mary Ellen McDonald and six from the second to Emma
Fairly.
Glen Summit also listed eight children and noted the first two, Mary
and John
William, were probably from a previous marriage.
Combining information
from Mrs.
Rust and Mr. Summit, the children of James William Swank were:
Mary Jane "Molly" Swank m. Ed Taliaferro
John Swank m. Anna May Luiton
Lula (Talula) Alice Swank, b. 10 March 1871 in Texas, m. A. M.
Shipe
James Clay Swank, b. 13 Oct 1872 in Texas, m. Maggie Maulding
Robert E. Lee Swank b. 8 Feb 1876, never married
Emma Belle Swank b. 10 Dec 1877 in Turners Bend on Brazos River,
Somervell Co, Tx, never married
Katie Effie Swank b. 8 Aug 1878, died young
Minnie Ella Swank b. 24 March 1880 in Texas, never married
James William Swank
died on 14
Sept 1881 and was buried in Squaw Creek Cemetery, Rainbow, Somervell
County,
Texas. Emma Fairly Swank then married Perry Lincoln Embree in 1883 and
had
three children with him between 1884 and 1894. Since the letter from
David to
her was dated 1896, he obviously kept up with her even after her second
marriage and family. Referring to his nephew, he said, "our fathers
fought
under Gen Wayne and his father under Washington. Our father was born in
Ky.
during the first settlements of that State in a fort owned by our
Grandfather.
Will's Grandma on our side was born in the same state in a fort owned
by her Pa
where Louisville Ky. now stands. Her people are Vanmeters Hay Cooffs
Nandius
and Ex president Tyler. All of the most leading families of that state.
Will's
Ma was a Miss Mary Quigly whose father died whilst she was quite young
but [who
was] one of the leading men of that day."
Amanda Miller was the
daughter of
Pamelia (Pamela or Permelia) Caroline Carothers and Robert Richardson
Miller.
R.R. Miller was born in Virginia on 10 Apr 1809 and died on 25 Sept
1876.
Pamelia Carothers was born in Tennessee on 14 Nov 1814 and died 6 Mar
1859. Her
family was of Scot/Irish roots. Pamelia and R. R. were married 6 Jan
1831
according to an entry in the family Bible. In 1850 the family was
living in
Union Township of St. Francis County, Arkansas. By 1860, the Miller
family had
moved to Greene County, Arkansas and settled in St. Francis Township.
After
Pamelia's death in 1859, Robert Miller married again because the 1860
census
listed his wife as Matilda. It also listed him as owning real property
worth
$3,000 and personal property valued at $1,800. $4,800 in 1860 would be
$104,347
in 2002 dollars. In the 1870 census, R. R. was listed as blind, but he
was
obviously a man of some substance. Pages from the family Bible list the
births
and deaths of these children:
** Amanda Miller (24 Dec 1831- )
John Middleton Miller (9 Mar 1833-
)
Martha Miller (23 Sept 1834-
) married Jacob "Jake" Swank, David's nephew, Oct 1852
Mary Miller (9 Aug 1836- )
married John Armstrong
Jane Miller (23 Aug 1838- )
married Noble J. Self, Oct 1861
Lucinda Miller (25 Feb 1840-29 Aug 1844)
Elisabeth Miller (7 Dec 1841-
) married Elisha Bobo, 14 Mar 1861 (?)
James Marshall Miller (16 Apr 1843-30 Jan 1854)
Jacob Morris Miller (6 Jan 1845-
)
Virginia Miller (5 Dec 1846-
) married James Thompson 28 June 1866
Robert Carothers Miller (5 May 1849-14 Sept 1850)
William Samuel Miller (4 Apr 1851-
) married Mary Victoria Stepp
Amanda
Miller was born on 24 Dec 1831 in Arkansas. A family
story says that she was a good horsewoman (perhaps her Virginia
heritage) and
that she and David Swank met when he rescued her as she tried to ride
across a
swollen stream. Amanda and David Swank married in 15 March 1849. In the
1850
census, she was listed as living with her parents. That was because
David was
at the California Gold Rush. Their first child was born on 22 Dec 1849,
but
their second not until 24 Apr 1852 so either she lost a baby or David
didn't
get back from the California gold fields until the middle of 1851.
In 1980, a
granddaughter of
William Samuel Miller, Amanda's youngest brother, reminisced about her
Miller
ancestors. She remembered Jacob Morris Miller, "Uncle Jake," as being
of very small stature, as were all the Millers, it seems. She
remembered her
great aunts Virginia Miller Thompson, whom she called "Aunt Vir" and
Elisabeth Miller Bobo whom she called "Aunt Liz." Virginia named two
of her daughters after her sisters, one being Amanda and the other
Elisabeth,
whom the granddaughter called "Aunt Lizzie." In later years, Virginia
told stories about when her father lived in Virginia and owned slaves.
"On
Sunday mornings when they were preparing to go to church, they would
have
slaves put 'grease' (bacon?) on their faces so they would look well
fed.
Negroes tend to look 'ashey' when they are poorly fed," she explained.
According to the 1830 census, Richard Miller had four slaves and
William
Carothers, Pamelia's father, had five. In the 1840 census, Mr.
Carothers had
nine slaves. Both Edward Miller Carl Sr. and Jr. were given the Miller
name to
honor Amanda's family.
A hand-detailed
photograph of
Amanda Miller Swank and her daughter Mary Elizabeth Swank. Since Mary
was born
in Dec 1853, the image probably dates to around 1857. This would be
about the
time David and Amanda moved from MO to TX. Mary remembered being around
5 when they
moved.
We have a
transcription of a
letter Mary Swank wrote. In it she says about her father, "The Rev.
David
Swank was born in Harden, now LaRue county Ky. Sept. 15, 1823 in the
community
with Abraham Lincoln with whom he was intimately acquainted in his
early
manhood days. His mother was Elizabeth Vanmeter whose father settled in
Louisville, Ky. and was a cousin of President John Tyler; his father
Jacob
Swank faught under Mad Anthony Wayne and was with him at Stoney Point
and at
early age he my father migrated to Missouri, going into the general
merchandise
business at Charleston, of which city he served as mayor. After getting
burned
out at Charleston he went to California in 1849 to try to retrieve his
fortune.
Later he came to Texas and engaged in the merchantile business at
Wanahachie
first and then at Peora, in Will County. He voted against secession but
when it
carried he cast his lot with his adopted home Texas serving as
bookkeeper in
the quartermaster department at Wourton (Houston? Wharton?) for a time
and
afterwards as Captain of a company who guarded our frontier from the
Indians.
After the Civil War he removed with his family to Benton Co., Ark and
to this
union twelve children were born."
According to census,
Bible and
other records, David and Amanda Miller Swank's children were:
William Henry Swank b. 22 Dec 1849 in Arkansas, died in Texas,
murdered
by a Baptist preacher
David Hervey Swank b. 24 Apr 1852 in Arkansas[GS says 1851] m.
Susan
Bright, son, David Jr.
** Mary
Elizabeth Swank b. 6 Dec 1853 in Phillips Co, Arkansas [GS says Greene
Co.] m.
John H. Carl
Catherine Miller Swank b. 2 Dec 1855 in Arkansas and drowned in
Spavinaw
Creek, 16 July 1869
Alma Marshall Swank b. 14 Sept 1857 in Missouri; died single
Amanda Elizabeth Swank b. 26 May 1859 in Texas
[GS has Amanda Eliza Mittie Swank b. in Missouri]
Martha Ellen Swank b. 18 Aug 1861 in Texas [GS says Charleston],
m.
Zelph (or Zeph) Phillips 27 Apr 1880 and d. 21 June 1883
Charlie Pierce Swank b. 22 May 1864 in Texas, d. 8 Aug 1866
Samuel Jacob Swank b. 27 Apr 1866 in Texas; died single
John Walter Swank b. 24 Sept 1868 in Arkansas and killed in a
mine
accident 3 Sept 1884
Robert Richardson Swank b. 5 Sept 1869 [GS says Sept 1871]
Laura Jane Swank b. 26 May 1873
David
Swank was a lay Methodist minister and circuit rider.
In addition, he became a gold prospector in 1849, the same year he and
Amanda married,
when he, along with some of his brothers, took part in the California
Gold
Rush. From birth records of their children, it appears David and Amanda
moved
from Arkansas to Missouri sometime between 1855 and 1857 since their
child Alma
Marshall was born 14 Sept 1857 in Missouri. They then moved from
Missouri to
Texas during the period 1857-1859. This matches what their daughter
Mary said
in later years, that she was about five years old at the time. She also
said
the move occurred on the advice of a doctor in Missouri. Amanda
suffered from a
health condition and it was thought she needed the dry air of Texas for
recovery. Another theory, advanced by Ed Carl, Jr. was that David
foresaw the
coming of the Civil War and did not wish to become involved or to
subject his
family to the possible hazards of war. For whatever reason, David moved
his
family and settled on Paluxy Creek, which was near what is now Glen
Rose, west
of Ft. Worth. Mary often reminisced about the times she and her
brothers and
sisters would go down to the stream to play and gather wild mustang
grapes.
They later moved to Johnson County, near the Brazos river. Once
established in
a log cabin, David began raising horses and cows. He eventually was
appointed a
captain of a local Ranger company for protection from raiding Indian
groups.
Once, when he and the local rangers were away, Indians raided their
home and
stole their horses. She was later quoted as saying she lived through
many
Indian raids and on more than one occasion manned the powder horn while
the men
prepared the long muzzle-loaders. One time, as Mary told the story,
Amanda
noticed corn missing from their corn crib. That night she told her
children to
hide, got her musket, opened their cabin door and waited for the thief
to go
by. She called a warning, then shot into the darkness. The next day the
children saw their neighborhood doctor sitting on a grapevine on Paluxy
Creek,
bleeding. Not all the people who stole in those days were Indians!
The record in the
family Bible
states that David and Amanda's daughter, Amanda Elizabeth Swank was
born on 26
May 1859 in Texas. Glen Summit listed her name as Amanda Eliza Mittie
Swank.
Information on the Swanks compiled by Mrs. Elma Rust and sent to my
father, Ed
Carl, Jr. in 1979 also listed Amanda that way. According to Mrs. Rust,
Amanda
Eliza Mittie was born in 1859, married in 1885 Gustave Ferdinand Von
Fintel and
with him had four children: Gus. F. Jr. (1886-1909); Edward Henry
(1888-1907);
Jennie Mittie (1889- ); and Elizabeth Rhea (1891- ). My father admitted
that
until he saw the information, he hadn't known which of David and
Amanda's
children was 'Mittie.' He remembered meeting 'Aunt Mit' when he was in
high
school. and she came to visit her sister, Mary, Ed's grandmother. He
noted that
both women were small and dainty, but very active and sturdy. "Aunt Mit
was a 'honey blonde' with blue eyes, both of which she inherited from
her
father. Grandma Carl had jet black hair and dark eyes, which she
inherited from
her mother, Amanda." A death notice for Mary Carl in 1949 noted that
her
sister, Mrs. Mittie von Fintel of Indian, Oklahoma was one of her
survivors.
This photograph shows
Mary
Elizabeth Swank Carl, left, and her sister Amanda 'Mittie' Swank Von
Fintell,
right. Also shown are Minnie Carl and her son J. W. Carl. The sisters
are too
old to show the stark difference in their coloring, but younger
pictures of
Mary show how dark her hair and eyes were.
Unfortunately, Mrs.
Rust's list
also had Mary marrying a John H. Earl (instead of Carl), two of their
sons
marrying women named Bouner (instead of Bonner), one son being named
David
Harvey instead of David Hervey and another son marrying a woman named
Wilderman
(instead of Wideman) - incorrect information that was assumed correct
by later
researchers. Mrs. Rust may have been the source of the errors or passed
them
along from somewhere else. In addition, her list noted that David and
Amanda's
son David married a Susan Bright and had a son, David H. Jr.; that
their
daughter, Martha Ellen married Zeph Phillips but had no children; and
that
Laura Jane married a Mr. Swimford and had a child, Earl. Both Glen
Summit and
Karalee Goranflo list Martha Ellen's husband as Zelph Phillips. Mrs.
Rust
obviously worked very hard in compiling information on the Swanks and
in 1982
published a 172 page book entitled "John Swank, ca. 1750-1794, and some
of
his descendents." Even with the mistakes on some of my family, her
report
is still a helpful source of information.
According to
genealogical records,
David must have moved his family back to Arkansas between 1866 and 1868
because
a son was born in Texas on 27 Apr 1866 and another son in Arkansas on
24 Sept
1868. We have a copy of a receipt dated 6 Dec 1866 and signed by Amanda
Swank
selling her entire stock of cattle running within Hood, Johnson, Erath,
Bosque
and Hill counties in Texas for $475. Perhaps they were liquidating
their
property before they moved. The 1870 census for Round Prairie Township,
Benton
County, Arkansas lists David, Amanda, their children William, David,
Alma,
Amanda, Ellen, Samuel and John and a housekeeper named Virginia. David
was
listed as a farmer and Alma, Amanda, Ellen and Samuel were students.
David and
Amanda didn't stay in Arkansas, however. After the California Gold
Rush, there
was a Silver and Gold Rush in Colorado in the 1870s and 1880s.
According to
Mary, David and Amanda Swank and some of their family joined that Rush
along
with Mary's husband, John H. Carl. The timing of this journey was
referred to
years later by one of David's grandsons. Newt Carl said his
"Grandfather
Swank, Uncle Al, Uncle Dave" and his Father left with the gold rush for
Ledville, Colorado a little while after his sister Ella was born, in
March
1879. In the 1880 census for Osage Township, Benton County, Arkansas,
the Swank
family name was listed, but David himself wasn't named. He was noted as
being
55, white and married. Amanda was 53, a wife and housekeeper. Their son
David
(the "Uncle Dave" from Newt's letter) was listed as being 27, a
farmer and a widower. In the letter David Swank wrote to Emma Embree in
1896,
he mentioned "the trouble in which my son Dave got into here arose from
leaving his wife." David went on to say Dave's wife had an
uncontrollable
temper, that he stood it for 11 years and then divided (separated?) and
left.
He also said that Dave's brother and sisters in Colorado were doing
well. The next child listed in the 1880
census was Allen ("Uncle Al?"), 23, single and a farmer. That confused
me because I thought the child born after David, Alma Marshall Swank,
was
female, but the child was listed as male in the 1870 census as well as
the
1880, though in 1870 the name was listed as Alana and in 1880 as Allen.
To make
things more confusing, we have a copy of a calling card for Alma M.
Swank that
has a bouquet of flowers on it and looks very feminine. One of David
and
Amanda's grandsons, J.F. Carl, named his daughter Alma. If Newt's
memories were
correct, David could have been in Colorado when the census enumerator
came to
call on 5 June 1880, but if so, Al and Dave weren't with him, at least
on that
day. Continuing down the 1880 census list, Mittie was 19 and a teacher;
Samuel,
15, John, 13 and Robert 10, were at school. Laura, 6, was not.
The calling card looks
very
feminine for a man. But if Alma were a woman, who was Uncle Al Swank
and why
did two census reports say he was male? One of those little family
mysteries.
Whatever the timing,
the trek to
Colorado occurred and resulted in two tragedies. Amanda died on 12
October 1881
and was buried in Denver, and one of David and Amanda's sons, John
Walter
Swank, was killed in a mine accident on 3 Sept 1884, just a few weeks
before he
turned 16. In later years, Mary used large chunks of gold and silver
quartz
rock for door-stoppers as mementos of her Swank family's trek to
Colorado. In
addition to being a minister and prospector, David seems to have also
been an
expert in homeopathic medicine and passed that knowledge on to his
daughter.
His grandson graduated from Dr. David Swank's School of Pantherapy and
Osteopathology in 1902. It's possible that the 'Dr. David Swank' who
ran the
school could have been the Rev. Swank's son David, but the older Swank
was
alive in 1902 so the school could have just as well been his. David
Swank Sr.
eventually moved back to Texas. In the letter David wrote Emma Embree
in 1896,
he said he sometimes felt bad when he thought of the past, the loss of
his wife
and six children. "How sadly I am. Poor in this world's goods. No
permanent home. a wayfairing man. I look forward to the day when I
shall meet
those gone before. My dear niece and children I may never see you in
this life
as I do not think [it] possible for me to pay you a visit. I am so poor
and
old. You see from my writing that I am so nervous. I hope this may find
you all
well and God's blessings resting upon you." David Swank died in
Corsicana
from myocarditis, or inflammation of the heart muscle, on 11 Feb 1906
and is
buried in Pettys Chapel Cemetery.
In
addition to being a Methodist minister, a gold prospector,
a farmer, rancher, ranger and father, David Swank was a poet. We have
copies of
two of his poems written in 1879 and another undated one. The ones with
titles
are Only a While and O Lord Let Me Do Thy Bidding. The first two are
from
photocopies. I have the original of the third one.
Amanda Miller and the Rev. David Swank were the parents of Mary Elizabeth Swank who was born on 6 Dec 1853 in Phillips County, Arkansas. (In a letter written by Mary's son Newt in 1952, he said she was born either in Northeast Arkansas or Charleston, Missouri, but the record in the family Bible says Phillips County, Arkansas.) According to Wanda Pyburn, Mary's great granddaughter through Tom Carl, Mary was taught 'homeopathic medicine' from her father, David Swank. It was said that "when the men were away at [the Civil] war she kept the women and children from starving in the winter by collecting roots and herbs in the forest."